Under-eye Bags
Under-eye bags are a shape, and dark circles are a colour. They are often discussed together and they frequently occur together, but they have separate causes and separate answers, and mistaking one for the other is why a great deal of eye cream disappoints.
Two different things produce the shape. The first is fluid: lying flat overnight, a salty meal, alcohol, crying, or an allergic reaction lets fluid pool in the very thin, loosely attached skin under the eye. This kind is transient, worst in the morning, and improves by itself within hours. The second is structural. The membrane that holds the orbital fat pad in place weakens with age, and the fat that cushions the eyeball begins to press forward against the skin. That version does not fluctuate, does not improve with sleep, and is generally more pronounced by evening in photographs rather than in the mirror.
What skincare can honestly do addresses only the first kind. Cold constricts blood vessels and moves fluid, which is why a chilled compress or a cool metal applicator works for twenty minutes or so. Caffeine does the same thing chemically and just as temporarily. Sleeping with the head slightly raised reduces overnight pooling. Managing an allergy — the puffiness of allergic shiners is genuinely allergic — often does more than any product.
What no topical does is reposition fat. Retinoids and peptides can improve the quality and thickness of the skin over time, which softens the appearance of the transition, but the bulge itself is anatomy. Blepharoplasty and injectable filler placed in the hollow below the bulge are the interventions that change it, and both are procedures rather than products. A cream that promises to remove a structural bag is describing something it cannot do.